Judgejudy

5 clues
No-nonsense arbiter
No-nonsense TV jurist
No-nonsense TV decider
Highly rated court figure
Highest-paid TV star of 2014, by far
Similar answers:
Aaronjudge
Adjudge
Adjudged
Adjudges
Ajudgeishouldve
Ajudgmentcall
Apoorjudgeofanatomy
Appellatejudge
Arlinejudge
Assoberasajudge
Backjudge
Backjudges
Bemyjudge
Brandeisjudges
Cartoonistjudge
Circuitjudge
Circuitjudges
Dayofjudgment
Dayojudgment
Districtjudge