| Weirdest |
| Strangest |
| Spookiest |
| Most scary |
| Most weird |
| Most creepy |
| Most spooky |
| Most macabre |
| Most uncanny |
| Most strange |
| Most unusual |
| Most chilling |
| Most peculiar |
| Most unnerving |
| Most unworldly |
| Most unearthly |
| Most mysterious |
| Most unsettling |
| Supremely spooky |
| Least explainable |
| Maximally uncanny |
| Most supernatural |
| Freaky to the max |
| Spooky to the max |
| Most inexplicable |
| Most Halloweenlike |
| Most spine-chilling |
| Chilling to the max |
| Most chill-inducing |
| Most spine-tingling |
| Superlatively weird |
| Have the ___ feeling |
| Most weirdly strange |
| Superlatively spooky |
| Superlatively strange |
| Halloween superlative |
| Most goosebump-inducing |
| Like the best occult films |
| Otherworldly in the extreme |
| Causing the most goose bumps |
| Most likely to cause goose flesh |
| Most likely to cause horripilation |
| Like H. P. Lovecraft among all popular writers? |